Appetizers
Raw Bar
Truly Fresh Fish
Soups
Salads
Sides
Burgers
Hand Helds
House Specialties
Wood Burning Grill
Entrées
Kids Menu
Dessert Menu
Happy Hour
Drinks Menu

Appetizers

Conch Fritters

(8) $10.95
(16) $15.95

A specialty served with Harbor Island fritter sauce.

Alligator Tid Bits

$13.95

Naturally chewy, but very flavorful. A Conchy Joe’s original.

Joe’s Smoked Fish Dip

$13.95

Our fish dip is made with 100% Mahi-Mahi, smoked in house and served with all the fixin’s. A must try!

Shrimp Stack

$13.95

Fresh mandarin salsa, succulent Shrimp and diced avocado are stacked high and served with fresh tortilla chips.

Jerked Chicken Nachos

$12.95

Tortilla chips piled high and topped with jerked chicken, peppers, black beans, shredded Cheddar-Jack cheese, jalapenos and cilantro sour cream.

Crispy Fried Calamari

$13.95

Tender calamari fried golden brown with artichoke hearts and banana peppers, served with garlic aioli and Marinara.

Premium Chicken Wings

$13.95

Breaded buffalo wings served with sauce on the side so they stay crunchy.

Bahamian Conch Salad

$13.95

Marinated Conch with peppers, onions, celery, fresh lime juice and secret spices.

Raw Bar

WARNING: There is risk associated with consuming raw oysters. If you have chronic illness of the liver, stomach or blood or have immune disorders, you are at greater risk of serious illness from raw oysters and should eat oysters fully cooked. If unsure of your risk, consult a physician.

Florida Middleneck Clams

1/2 dozen – $6.95
1 dozen – $11.95

On the 1/2 shell or steamed.

Cold Water Oysters

1/2 dozen – $10.95
1 dozen – $18.95

On the 1/2 shell or steamed.

Oysters Romanoff

$14.95

Six fresh cold water oysters are topped with red onion, sour cream and caviar.

PEI Steamed Mussels

$12.95

Served with our tasty tequila butter.

U-Peel-Em Shrimp

1/2 lb – $13.95
1 lb – $23.95

Served cold or steamed.

Shrimp Cocktail

$2.50/Shrimp

U-15 Jumbos, served with house cocktail sauce.

Raw Bar Medley

$14.95

Locally made smoked fish dip, 3 clams, 3 oysters and 4 u-peel-em shrimp.

Snow Crab

MP

Truly Fresh Fish

Truly Fresh Fish, No Compromises.
Frozen, last year’s frozen, previously frozen, caught and immediately frozen, vacuum sealed frozen, and the list goes on. Sure we could use any of these inferior products to save money, but we NEVER will. At Conchy Joe’s it is our passion and our mission to prepare the freshest, tastiest fish dishes. We serve only TRULY FRESH FISH, NO COMPROMISES!

Please call 772.334.1130 or check our Weekly Specials posts on our Facebook Page for current available fresh fish options with market prices.

We can’t control the price of fresh fish but what we can do is give you a truly incredible Conchy experience by adding a bowl of our famous Conch Chowder and a piece of our house made Key Lime pie. Sorry folks this offer only extends to our Fresh Fish aficionados.

CHOOSE: 5oz. Fresh Fish Sandwich OR 8oz. Fresh Fish Entree

All fish available are prepared grilled, broiled, blackened, jerked, panko or crunchy fried. OR try one of our delicious original preparations .

Sweet Potato Crusted

A house favorite, topped with honey butter.

Soups

NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER

$7.95

A recipe from our original chef, who learned her trade in Bar Harbor, Maine.

CONCHY’S FAMOUS CONCH CHOWDER

$7.95

Made from scratch, it’s thick, chunky and flavorful. This famous recipe was requested by both Gourmet and Bon Appetit Magazines!

Salads

Conchy’s Seasonal Salad

Ask your Server!

We will change our Seasonal Salad based on the freshest produce currently available to take advantage of the season’s most delectable and savory crops. Ask your server what our current salad offering is for this season! Prices will vary as well.

Conchy’s Tropical Salad

$11.95

Fresh leaf lettuce, diced pineapple, chopped mango, sliced tomato, red onion and shredded coconut with our Pina Colada Vinaigrette dressing served on the side.

Conchy’s Caesar Salad

$11.95

Our home-made Caesar Dressing, romaine lettuce, cucumber, baby corn, black olives, red onion, fresh baked croutons and shredded Parmesan cheese.

Top any of our fresh made salads:

Chicken $6.00
Shrimp $8.00
Coconut Shrimp $8.00
Truly Fresh Catch of the Day MP

Sides

Choice of: Side Salad, Side Caesar Salad, French Fries, Mango Glazed Plantains, Black Beans and Yellow Rice, Coleslaw, Baked Potato, Mashed Potatoes and Vegetable Of The Day.

Burgers

Conchy’s Famous “Works” Burger (Or Famous “Works” Cheeseburger)
If you don’t want the “works” on your burger, 1950’s drive-in style, don’t order one of these! We season half a pound of cheap ground chuck with eleven secret herbs and spices, fry it up in a pan full of grease and serve it on a stale sesame seed bun with mustard, ketchup, mayonnaise, pickles, lots of thin sliced onions, lettuce and tomato. That’s the only way we serve it. Well, there is one option: Cheddar cheese, i.e. the Famous “Works” Cheeseburger. And you can order it cooked anyway you like: rare, rare medium rare, medium rare, medium rare medium, medium, medium well, well medium well or burned to a crisp. You’ll get it cooked medium (or thereabouts) no matter how you order it, but you can order it anyway you like – after all, it’s a free country, right? These are the only options: Cheeseburger or no Cheeseburger. Any other changes would destroy the integrity of this resurrected American Icon, and we won’t let this happen, we don’t care how important you are! We have clout too, we know someone whose brother’s wife is best friends with ex-Vice Pres. Dan Quayle’s mother-in-law, so don’t try to make us change this burger. No “hold the pickles” here, this ain’t no Mickey D’s, dig? (That’s fifties talk). As Sheriff Taylor put it, “Gooooodburger!”

Warning: These burgers are not recommended for people or farm animals with high blood pressure, heart disease, bad choppers, gastiophlabbilicktus or political ambitions. Also, they’re messy, sloppy and they’ll get greasy juice all over your hands, chin and clothes- Conchy Joe’s will not be held responsible!

Conchy’s Works Burger

$12.95

Conchy’s Works Cheeseburger

$13.95

Hamburger

$12.95

Cheeseburger

$13.95

Bacon Burger

$13.95

Bacon Cheeseburger

$14.95

Hand Helds

Cuban Sandwich

$14.95

Roasted mojo pork, thinly sliced Black Forest ham, Swiss cheese, dill pickles and yellow mustard are stacked into fresh Cuban bread before being pressed. Served with mango glazed plantains.

Chickee “Not Tiki” Tacos

$14.95

Fried Shrimp are tossed in a Caribbean remoulade, placed into warm flour tortillas, topped with pickled onions, shredded cabbage and Feta cheese.

Conch Burger

$15.95

Our original Conch burger served on a toasted brioche bun and topped with a chili lime slaw.

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$12.95

Fried chicken breast dipped in our house buffalo sauce and topped with Jack cheese. Served with blue cheese dressing.

Fresh Catch Sandwich

MP

Truly fresh fish prepared grilled, broiled, blackened, jerked, fried or crunchy fried.

Fish Tacos

MP

Tender, flaky blackened Dolphin placed into warm flour tortillas with Creole mayo, diced tomato, Pepper-Jack cheese and coleslaw.

Jacks Hackensack

$13.95

Ham, salami, capicola and pepperoni piled high on a hoagie roll with shredded lettuce, tomato, melted mozzarella, hot peppers, olive oil and red wine vinegar.

House Specialties

Bahamian Cracked Conch

$23.95

Queen Conch is hand tenderized, breaded and lightly fried. Delicious, but be warned, Conch is inherently chewy in texture.

Sauteed Seafood Trinidad

$28.95

Shrimp, fresh fish, diced tomatoes and spinach are sautéed with secret spices and finished with a sweet Caribbean cream sauce. Served over linguine pasta.

Seafood Mac and Cheese

$25.95

Scallops, shrimp and bacon are folded into a Gouda cheese sauce, tossed with cavatappi pasta and topped with bread crumbs.

Conchy’s Seafood Feast

$31.95

1/4 lb of u-peel-em shrimp, 1/4 lb of PEI mussels, 1/4 lb of Dungeness Crab, 6 Florida clams, chorizo, corn and red potatoes are tossed in Old Bay Tequila butter.

Conch Stuffed Shrimp

$24.95

White shrimp stuffed with our unique conch stuffing baked and topped with a sherry cream sauce. Served with yellow rice.

From Our Wood Burning Grill

Grilled meats are a big deal to us. That’s why we use all of our Choice Grade Steaks daily, grill them over Black Jack Oak and serve them on a sizzling platter. Simple is the recipe when you buy quality meats, and with that being said… we’ll let the taste do the rest of the talking.

Chicken Chimichurri

$19.95

Chicken seasoned with chili powder, grilled over Blackjack oak and topped with chimichurri sauce. Served with yellow rice and black bean puree.

Smothered Chicken

$19.95

Mesquite rubbed chicken breasts grilled and topped with honey mustard, sautéed mushrooms and onions and melted Cheddar-Jack cheese. Served with house made mashed potatoes.

Filet Mignon

$30.95

8 oz. Center Cut Filet

NY Strip

$30.95

12 oz. center cut strip served on a sizzling platter.

Entrées

Fried Shrimp

$23.95

Panko hand-breaded Shrimp, lightly fried and served with our house cocktail sauce.

Coconut Fried Shrimp

$23.95

Sweet coconut-breaded Shrimp, lightly fried and served with mango chutney.

Snow Crab Dinner

MP

1 lb. of crab served with drawn butter.

Dungeness Crab Dinner

MP

1 lb. of crab served with drawn butter.

Entrée Sides

All entrees, dishes from our wood burning grill and hand heads are served with your choice of side. Add a bowl of clam chowder for $3.95 or a bowl of conch chowder rom $4.95.

Choice of: Side Salad, Side Caesar Salad, French Fries, Mango Glazed Plantains, Black Beans and Yellow Rice, Coleslaw, Baked Potato, Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Potato Fries and Vegetable Of The Day.

Kids Menu

For Little “Conchs” 12 Years And Younger

All items are served with your choice of French fries, coleslaw, applesauce or yellow rice. (Excludes pasta dish.)

Kids Chicken Dinner

$6.95

All Beef Hot Dog

$5.95

Cheeseburger Platter

$9.95

Hamburger Platter

$8.95

Popcorn Shrimp

$7.95

Grilled Cheese

$5.95

Cheese Quesadilla

$5.95

Kids Pasta (with tomato sauce or butter)

$5.95

Dessert Menu

Conchy Joe’s Original Key Lime Pie

Slice: $6.00
Whole Pie To-Go: $20.00

A house favorite for 30 years! We can’t tell you how we make it but it’s nearly world famous, and for good reason.

Tortuga Caribbean Rum Cake

$10.00

Golden Cake soaked in 5 year old Tortuga rum is topped with chunks of fresh pineapple and rum infused icing.

Peanut Butter Pie

Slice: $7.00
Whole Pie To-Go: $23.00

A delicious, homemade peanut butter pie prepared with graham cracker crust, chocolate chips and rich, whipped peanut butter.

Chocolate Lava Cake

$7.50

Warm chocolate cake filled with rich ganache, accompanied by vanilla ice cream and whip cream.

Ice Cream

1 Scoop: $2.50
2 Scoops: $4.00

Choose from Chocolate or Vanilla.

Happy Hour Menu

3-6pm Every Day
Buy One Get One On Domestic Drafts, House Wine And Well Drinks. “Almost Free Happy Hour Menu” $6–$9 Appetizers.

WARNING: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness.

Conchy’s Deadly Foot

$7.00

One foot closer to six feet under. A foot-long hot dog is wrapped in bacon, deep fried and smothered in a sweet and spicy jalapeño relish and toasted bun.

Wonton Wrapped Shrimp

$7.00

Sweet chili marinated shrimp wrapped in wonton, fried golden brown, served with sweet chili dipping sauce.

Steamed Mussels

$7.00

Served with house Tequila butter.

Buffalo Shrimp

$6.00

Served with celery, carrots and Blue Cheese dressing.

Jerk Chicken Flatbread

$8.00

Grilled chicken placed on top of a crispy flatbread with bell peppers, onions, Mozzarella cheese, pineapples and jerk sauce.

Blackened Shrimp Tacos

$6.00

Blackened shrimp stuffed into mini taco shells with fresh pineapple salsa and Creole sauce.

Potato Skins

$6.00

Potato skins stuffed with melted Cheddar Jack cheese and bacon, then topped with jalapeño sour cream.

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

$8.00

Spinach and artichoke hearts are folded into Mozzarella and cream cheese. Served with tortilla chips.

Clams (6)

$4.50

Served Steamed or Raw.

Clams (12)

$9.00

DRINKS MENU

Frozen Drinks

St. Lucia Drunken Monkey

Light Rum and coffee liqueur blended with Pina colada mix and fresh bananas.

Pina Colada

Traditional favorite with light rum.

Strawberry Daiquiri

Another usual suspect with light rum.

Rumrunner

A belt of rums and juices, topped with 151 rum.

Mango Daiquiri

Same as a strawberry, but substitute mango.

Margaritas

Traditional, mango or strawberry. Don’t forget to ask for a Patron Silver, Reposado or Anejo.

Conchy Tinis

Apple Martini

Smirnoff Green Apple Vodka, DeKuyper Sour Apple Pucker and a splash of sour mix.

Cosmo

Absolute Vodka, DeKuyper Triple Sec and a splash of cranberry juice.

Raspberry Cosmo

Smirnoff Raspberry Vodka, DeKuyper Triple Sec and a splash of cranberry juice.

Lemon Drop-Tini

Smirnoff Citrus Vodka, sour mix and simple syrup with a sugar-coated rim.

The Pomegranate Martini

Absolut Citron Vodka and pomegranate liqueur, shaken and served up with a twist.

Specialty Margaritas

Patron Margarita

Patron Silver Tequila, triple sec, lime juice, sweet & sour mix and salted rim.

Golden Margarita

Jose Cuervo Especial Tequila, Bauchant Liqueur, sweet and sour mix, lime juice and a salted rim.

Jalapeno Margarita

Milagro Tequila, sliced jalapeños, triple sec, lime juice, sweet and sour mix and a salted rim.

Watermelon Margarita

Patron Silver Tequila, DeKuyper Watermelon Pucker Liqueur, sour mix and a sugar rim.

Truly Top Shelf Margarita

Patron Anejo, Grand Marnier with a splash of sour mix.

Featured Drinks

Big Conch

Our Signature Drink! This mega cocktail consists of 45oz. Of Conchy’s rum punch: A blend of fruit juice, secret stuff, four island rums topped with a Myer’s Rum Floater. For 2 or more only.

Little Conch

Conchy Joe’s signature drink, made with our own secret ingredients (mini-me version of the Big Conch)

Voodoo Hooch

Cruz Coconut, Pineapple and Mango Rums, orange juice, pineapple juice and dark rum, served in a 20oz. glass.

Bahama Mama

Cruz Coconut Rum, light rum, Tia Maria, orange juice, pineapple juice and grenadine.

Latitude Adjustment

Cruzan Coconut Rum, 151 rum, light rum, DeKuyper Triple Sec, Pineapple juice and orange juice.

Goombay Smash

Cruzan Coconut Rum, Mount Gay Rum, DeKuyper Apricot Brandy, orange juice and pineapple juice.

Dark ‘N Stormy

Goslig’s Black Seal Rum and Goslings Ginger Beer with a squeeze of lime.

Yellow Bird

Light rum, DeKuyper Creme de Banana, Galliano, orange juice, pineapple juice and Chambord.

American Mule

Tito’s Vodka and Goslings ginger beer with a squeeze of lime.

Pusser’s Pain Killer

Pusser’s dark rum, orange juice, pineapple juice, cream of coconut and ground nutmeg.

Hemmingway Daiquiri

Papa’s recipe; as served in the Florida Bar, Havana. Double shot of rum, lime juice, grapefruit juice and simple syrup. A house favorite, but go easy, they’re potent!

Mai Tai

Light and dark rums, DeKuyper Creme de Noyaux, DeKuyper Triple Sec, sour mix and orange juice.

Guana Grabber

Recipe stolen from Guana Beach Resort and Marina, Guana Cay. Bahamas Light Rum, Dark Rum, Cruzan Coconut Rum, Pineapple, Orange and grapefruit juices and a splash of grenadine.

Blue Lemonade

Absolut Citron Vodka and DeKuyper Blue Curacao, topped with lemonade.

Gorilla Punch

Vodka, DeKuyper Blue Curacao, pineapple juice and orange juice.

Mojito

Light rum, fresh mint and lime, muddle with sugar and topped with soda. Add some Mojo to your Mojito and choose from the Cruzan Flavored Rums: Coconut, Mango, or Pineapple.

Beer

Draft Beer

Bud Light
Miller Light
Yuengling
Sailfish Tag & Release
Blue Moon
Dogfish 60 Minute IPA
New Belgium Fat Tire
TBC Chancellor
Langunitas IPA
Walking Tree Pool day APA

Domestic

Miller Lite
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Angry Orchard
Michelob Ultra
Dogfish 90min IPA
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

Imported

Red Stripe
Corona
Heinecken
Kalik
Corona Light
Guiness
Stella Artois

Native Craft Beer

Key West Sunshine Ale
Wild Night
Screaming Reels IPA
Maduro Brown
Jai Lai IPA
White Marlin Wit
Sunrise IPA
Hop Gun IPA
Floridian Hefeweizen
Sandbar Sunday Wheat Ale
Citrus Ale
Shark Bait
Pulp Friction
La Colada Porter

Non-Alcoholic

St. Pauli Girl
Coors N.A.

Wine

House Wines

Copperridge, California

Chardonnay

Pinot Grigio

White Zinfandel

Cabernet Sauvignon

Merlot

Champagne & Sparkling Wines

Zonin Prosecco, Split

Zonin Sparkling Rose, Split

Freixenet Cordon Negro, Split

Moet & Chandon Imperial

Perrier Jouet

Reds

Merlot-Hogue
Columbia Valley, Washington

Red Blend-19 Crimes
Australia

Cabernet Sauvignon-Robert Mondavi
California

Pinot Noir-Lyric
California

Malbec-Dona Paul, Mendoza
Argenina

Rose-Breezette
Provence, France

Whites

Chardonnay-Kendall Jackson
California

Chardonnay-Sonoma Cutrer
Sonoma County

Pinot Grigio-Ecco Domani
Italy

Pinot Grigio-Maso Canali
Italy

Riesling-Relax
Germany

Sauvignon Blanc-Sterling
Napa County

Sauvignon Blanc-Whitehaven
New Zealand

White Sangria $6.00

Tea / Soda

Water

Perrier
$4.00

Evian
$4.00